How about we

sample unique and inventive PB&J sandwiches at Peanut Butter & Co., then take home our favorite peanut butters.

On the date

  • Get a cozy table for two at Peanut Butter & Co., which celebrates all things peanut butter.

  • Share specially-made off-menu PB&J sandwiches, paired with steaming cups of coffee.

  • Sample the shop’s other sticky treats. Crunchy or creamy? Sweet or savory? They have it all.

  • Pick your favorite jars of Peanut Butter & Co.’s all-natural products to enjoy at home.

Check Availability (optional)

Click a date on the calendar to view available reservation times. You'll be able to confirm or change your selected time after you book.

Select Date (optional)

Select Time (optional)

Made with love

Lee Zalben has had a lifelong passion for peanut butter...

In college, he and his friends competed to see who could make the wackiest, most delicious peanut butter sandwich. At 26, while Lee was working in the advertising industry, he spotted an empty storefront in Greenwich Village. He quit his job the next day and began to plan the Peanut Butter & Co. Sandwich Shop, and hasn’t looked back.

Lee Zalben Founder, Peanut Butter & Co.

The details

Date includes two custom HowAboutWe exclusive sandwiches, coffee and two jars of Peanut Butter & Co. products to take home.

Reservations available Sunday–Thursday between 11am–9pm, and Friday–Saturday between 11am–10pm.

This date must be redeemed by December 31st.

Tax and gratuity included.

Couples with peanut allergies should not book this date.

Subject to availability. Please allow two business days to complete reservations or to reschedule. All reservations and changes to reservations should be made through HowAboutWe.

No refunds or cancellations; one-time rescheduling only.


logo here

Peanut Butter & Co.
240 Sullivan Street
New York, NY 10012